Silicon: next steps for Genius


Robert Varga
 

Hello everyone,

as you may be aware, Genius has decided not to participate in Silicon
release as a managed project.

As it currently stands it would be subject to branching and
version-bumping at the Silicon branch and release points.

We do not want that to happen, as would result in genius.git/master to
become eventually unbuildable -- raising a high barrier of entry if
someone were to want give it a try. This has happened to each and every
ex-MSI project. We need and can do better.

What we want to achieve is that as soon as Silicon releases,
genius.git/master will be bumped to Silicon GA artifacts of its
upstreams. That way its build will not get broken once Silicon SNAPSHOT
artifacts expire and will remain buildable for pretty much eternity.

To get to that point, we need to remove Genius from autorelease and
int/dist before the Silicon branch point.

Any objections to doing that this or next week?

Regards,
Robert


Daniel de la Rosa
 

Just bumping this to make sure that there are no objections... 


On Tue, Jan 26, 2021 at 12:31 AM Robert Varga <nite@...> wrote:
Hello everyone,

as you may be aware, Genius has decided not to participate in Silicon
release as a managed project.

As it currently stands it would be subject to branching and
version-bumping at the Silicon branch and release points.

We do not want that to happen, as would result in genius.git/master to
become eventually unbuildable -- raising a high barrier of entry if
someone were to want give it a try. This has happened to each and every
ex-MSI project. We need and can do better.

What we want to achieve is that as soon as Silicon releases,
genius.git/master will be bumped to Silicon GA artifacts of its
upstreams. That way its build will not get broken once Silicon SNAPSHOT
artifacts expire and will remain buildable for pretty much eternity.

To get to that point, we need to remove Genius from autorelease and
int/dist before the Silicon branch point.

Any objections to doing that this or next week?

Regards,
Robert





Hema Gopalakrishnan
 

Hi Robert,

The steps that you have mentioned below is fine with us. Please go ahead.

Thanks,
Hema

-----Original Message-----
From: Robert Varga <nite@...>
Sent: Tuesday, January 26, 2021 2:01 PM
To: tsc@...; release@...
Cc: Hema Gopalkrishnan <hema.gopalkrishnan@...>; Faseela K <k.faseela@...>; Chetan Arakere Gowdru <chetan.arakere@...>
Subject: Silicon: next steps for Genius

Hello everyone,

as you may be aware, Genius has decided not to participate in Silicon release as a managed project.

As it currently stands it would be subject to branching and version-bumping at the Silicon branch and release points.

We do not want that to happen, as would result in genius.git/master to become eventually unbuildable -- raising a high barrier of entry if someone were to want give it a try. This has happened to each and every ex-MSI project. We need and can do better.

What we want to achieve is that as soon as Silicon releases, genius.git/master will be bumped to Silicon GA artifacts of its upstreams. That way its build will not get broken once Silicon SNAPSHOT artifacts expire and will remain buildable for pretty much eternity.

To get to that point, we need to remove Genius from autorelease and int/dist before the Silicon branch point.

Any objections to doing that this or next week?

Regards,
Robert