integration-dev@lists.opendaylight.org | SNMP plugin system test

Luis Gomez <luis.gomez@...>

Hi Paiwei,

We are currently building a test bed for OpenDaylight system test, so I would need some information from SNMP project. In your case I see you are using existing SAL services (like Flow Programmer) to integrate SNMP Ethernet switches into SDN. Now my question is: 

1) What kind of SNMP switch device are you using in your development? 
2) Can we get something similar to do system test? otherwise any recommendation for doing system test?

Thanks/Luis

Luis Gomez <luis.gomez@...>

#222

Thanks Christine, just let us know when you have a switch we can test with as well as when your API/features get finalized.

Show quoted text

-----Original Message-----
From: ylhsieh@... [mailto:ylhsieh@...] 
Sent: Monday, November 04, 2013 11:17 PM
To: Luis Gomez
Cc: pwwang@...; chilung@...
Subject: RE: SNMP plugin system test

Hi Luis,

Apologies of replying so late due to mail missing...

We use off-the-shelf commodity Ethernet switches, from D-Link and Edge-Core. For the case of testing without real switches, we tried to find something like Mininet for Ethernet switch, but not yet find a workable one. This issue is also important to us, if we find out a solution, will let you know ASAP.

Thanks!
Christine

________________________________________
寄件者: Luis Gomez [luis.gomez@...]
寄件日期: 2013年10月24日 上午 02:38
收件者: 王派偉; 謝宜玲
副本: 'integration-dev@...'; 'infrastructure@...'
主旨: SNMP plugin system test

Hi Paiwei,

We are currently building a test bed for OpenDaylight system test, so I would need some information from SNMP project. In your case I see you are using existing SAL services (like Flow Programmer) to integrate SNMP Ethernet switches into SDN. Now my question is:

1) What kind of SNMP switch device are you using in your development?
2) Can we get something similar to do system test? otherwise any recommendation for doing system test?

Thanks/Luis

====================================================================
本信件可能包含工研院機密資訊，非指定之收件者，請勿使用或揭露本信件內容，並請銷毀此信件。 
This email may contain confidential information. Please do not use or disclose it in any way and delete it if you are not the intended recipient.

ylhsieh@...

#230

Sure. :)

By the way, if you know or if you have heard of any kind of Ethernet switch simulator, please feel free to tell us, we are glad to try.

Thanks.
Christine

Show quoted text

-----Original Message-----
From: Luis Gomez [mailto:luis.gomez@...] 
Sent: Saturday, November 09, 2013 7:00 AM
To: 謝宜玲
Cc: 王派偉; 王啟龍; 'integration-dev@...'
Subject: RE: SNMP plugin system test

Thanks Christine, just let us know when you have a switch we can test with as well as when your API/features get finalized.

-----Original Message-----
From: ylhsieh@... [mailto:ylhsieh@...] 
Sent: Monday, November 04, 2013 11:17 PM
To: Luis Gomez
Cc: pwwang@...; chilung@...
Subject: RE: SNMP plugin system test

Hi Luis,

Apologies of replying so late due to mail missing...

We use off-the-shelf commodity Ethernet switches, from D-Link and Edge-Core. For the case of testing without real switches, we tried to find something like Mininet for Ethernet switch, but not yet find a workable one. This issue is also important to us, if we find out a solution, will let you know ASAP.

Thanks!
Christine

________________________________________
寄件者: Luis Gomez [luis.gomez@...]
寄件日期: 2013年10月24日 上午 02:38
收件者: 王派偉; 謝宜玲
副本: 'integration-dev@...'; 'infrastructure@...'
主旨: SNMP plugin system test

Hi Paiwei,

We are currently building a test bed for OpenDaylight system test, so I would need some information from SNMP project. In your case I see you are using existing SAL services (like Flow Programmer) to integrate SNMP Ethernet switches into SDN. Now my question is:

1) What kind of SNMP switch device are you using in your development?
2) Can we get something similar to do system test? otherwise any recommendation for doing system test?

Thanks/Luis

====================================================================
本信件可能包含工研院機密資訊，非指定之收件者，請勿使用或揭露本信件內容，並請銷毀此信件。 
This email may contain confidential information. Please do not use or disclose it in any way and delete it if you are not the intended recipient.

====================================================================
本信件可能包含工研院機密資訊，非指定之收件者，請勿使用或揭露本信件內容，並請銷毀此信件。 
This email may contain confidential information. Please do not use or disclose it in any way and delete it if you are not the intended recipient.

Luis Gomez <luis.gomez@...>

#233

OK Christine, I will open a task in Integration group to see if someone can help.

Show quoted text

-----Original Message-----
From: ylhsieh@... [mailto:ylhsieh@...] 
Sent: Monday, November 11, 2013 7:43 PM
To: Luis Gomez
Cc: pwwang@...; chilung@...; integration-dev@...
Subject: RE: SNMP plugin system test

Sure. :)

By the way, if you know or if you have heard of any kind of Ethernet switch simulator, please feel free to tell us, we are glad to try.

Thanks.
Christine

-----Original Message-----
From: Luis Gomez [mailto:luis.gomez@...] 
Sent: Saturday, November 09, 2013 7:00 AM
To: 謝宜玲
Cc: 王派偉; 王啟龍; 'integration-dev@...'
Subject: RE: SNMP plugin system test

Thanks Christine, just let us know when you have a switch we can test with as well as when your API/features get finalized.

-----Original Message-----
From: ylhsieh@... [mailto:ylhsieh@...] 
Sent: Monday, November 04, 2013 11:17 PM
To: Luis Gomez
Cc: pwwang@...; chilung@...
Subject: RE: SNMP plugin system test

Hi Luis,

Apologies of replying so late due to mail missing...

We use off-the-shelf commodity Ethernet switches, from D-Link and Edge-Core. For the case of testing without real switches, we tried to find something like Mininet for Ethernet switch, but not yet find a workable one. This issue is also important to us, if we find out a solution, will let you know ASAP.

Thanks!
Christine

________________________________________
寄件者: Luis Gomez [luis.gomez@...]
寄件日期: 2013年10月24日 上午 02:38
收件者: 王派偉; 謝宜玲
副本: 'integration-dev@...'; 'infrastructure@...'
主旨: SNMP plugin system test

Hi Paiwei,

We are currently building a test bed for OpenDaylight system test, so I would need some information from SNMP project. In your case I see you are using existing SAL services (like Flow Programmer) to integrate SNMP Ethernet switches into SDN. Now my question is:

1) What kind of SNMP switch device are you using in your development?
2) Can we get something similar to do system test? otherwise any recommendation for doing system test?

Thanks/Luis

====================================================================
本信件可能包含工研院機密資訊，非指定之收件者，請勿使用或揭露本信件內容，並請銷毀此信件。 
This email may contain confidential information. Please do not use or disclose it in any way and delete it if you are not the intended recipient.

====================================================================
本信件可能包含工研院機密資訊，非指定之收件者，請勿使用或揭露本信件內容，並請銷毀此信件。 
This email may contain confidential information. Please do not use or disclose it in any way and delete it if you are not the intended recipient.

Luis Gomez <luis.gomez@...>

#242

Hi Christine,

I have got suggestion from the group. Have you tried with quagga? http://www.nongnu.org/quagga/

BR/Luis

Show quoted text

-----Original Message-----
From: ylhsieh@... [mailto:ylhsieh@...] 
Sent: Monday, November 11, 2013 7:43 PM
To: Luis Gomez
Cc: pwwang@...; chilung@...; integration-dev@...
Subject: RE: SNMP plugin system test

Sure. :)

By the way, if you know or if you have heard of any kind of Ethernet switch simulator, please feel free to tell us, we are glad to try.

Thanks.
Christine

-----Original Message-----
From: Luis Gomez [mailto:luis.gomez@...] 
Sent: Saturday, November 09, 2013 7:00 AM
To: 謝宜玲
Cc: 王派偉; 王啟龍; 'integration-dev@...'
Subject: RE: SNMP plugin system test

Thanks Christine, just let us know when you have a switch we can test with as well as when your API/features get finalized.

-----Original Message-----
From: ylhsieh@... [mailto:ylhsieh@...] 
Sent: Monday, November 04, 2013 11:17 PM
To: Luis Gomez
Cc: pwwang@...; chilung@...
Subject: RE: SNMP plugin system test

Hi Luis,

Apologies of replying so late due to mail missing...

We use off-the-shelf commodity Ethernet switches, from D-Link and Edge-Core. For the case of testing without real switches, we tried to find something like Mininet for Ethernet switch, but not yet find a workable one. This issue is also important to us, if we find out a solution, will let you know ASAP.

Thanks!
Christine

________________________________________
寄件者: Luis Gomez [luis.gomez@...]
寄件日期: 2013年10月24日 上午 02:38
收件者: 王派偉; 謝宜玲
副本: 'integration-dev@...'; 'infrastructure@...'
主旨: SNMP plugin system test

Hi Paiwei,

We are currently building a test bed for OpenDaylight system test, so I would need some information from SNMP project. In your case I see you are using existing SAL services (like Flow Programmer) to integrate SNMP Ethernet switches into SDN. Now my question is:

1) What kind of SNMP switch device are you using in your development?
2) Can we get something similar to do system test? otherwise any recommendation for doing system test?

Thanks/Luis

====================================================================
本信件可能包含工研院機密資訊，非指定之收件者，請勿使用或揭露本信件內容，並請銷毀此信件。 
This email may contain confidential information. Please do not use or disclose it in any way and delete it if you are not the intended recipient.

====================================================================
本信件可能包含工研院機密資訊，非指定之收件者，請勿使用或揭露本信件內容，並請銷毀此信件。 
This email may contain confidential information. Please do not use or disclose it in any way and delete it if you are not the intended recipient.

ylhsieh@...

#246

Hi Luis,

Thank the group and thanks for the quick help. It seems quagga can simulate some protocols but is not a simulation switch.
Apologies that I didn't clearly describe the need for Ethernet switch simulator in SNMP4SDN. It is as follow: (1) Simulation Ethernet switch is needed for the snmp4sdn plugin so that the plugin can send SNMP query to the switch and receive SNMP reply from the switch. (2) (Optional) In further, if a simulation switch of specific vendor product is available, then, for the switch configuration not supported by SNMP (e.g. ACL configuration), the snmp4sdn plugin can configure the switch through CLI.

FYR.

BR/Christine

Show quoted text

-----Original Message-----
From: Luis Gomez [mailto:luis.gomez@...] 
Sent: Thursday, November 14, 2013 6:16 AM
To: 謝宜玲
Cc: 王派偉; 王啟龍; integration-dev@...
Subject: RE: SNMP plugin system test

Hi Christine,

I have got suggestion from the group. Have you tried with quagga? http://www.nongnu.org/quagga/

BR/Luis

-----Original Message-----
From: ylhsieh@... [mailto:ylhsieh@...] 
Sent: Monday, November 11, 2013 7:43 PM
To: Luis Gomez
Cc: pwwang@...; chilung@...; integration-dev@...
Subject: RE: SNMP plugin system test

Sure. :)

By the way, if you know or if you have heard of any kind of Ethernet switch simulator, please feel free to tell us, we are glad to try.

Thanks.
Christine

-----Original Message-----
From: Luis Gomez [mailto:luis.gomez@...] 
Sent: Saturday, November 09, 2013 7:00 AM
To: 謝宜玲
Cc: 王派偉; 王啟龍; 'integration-dev@...'
Subject: RE: SNMP plugin system test

Thanks Christine, just let us know when you have a switch we can test with as well as when your API/features get finalized.

-----Original Message-----
From: ylhsieh@... [mailto:ylhsieh@...] 
Sent: Monday, November 04, 2013 11:17 PM
To: Luis Gomez
Cc: pwwang@...; chilung@...
Subject: RE: SNMP plugin system test

Hi Luis,

Apologies of replying so late due to mail missing...

We use off-the-shelf commodity Ethernet switches, from D-Link and Edge-Core. For the case of testing without real switches, we tried to find something like Mininet for Ethernet switch, but not yet find a workable one. This issue is also important to us, if we find out a solution, will let you know ASAP.

Thanks!
Christine

________________________________________
寄件者: Luis Gomez [luis.gomez@...]
寄件日期: 2013年10月24日 上午 02:38
收件者: 王派偉; 謝宜玲
副本: 'integration-dev@...'; 'infrastructure@...'
主旨: SNMP plugin system test

Hi Paiwei,

We are currently building a test bed for OpenDaylight system test, so I would need some information from SNMP project. In your case I see you are using existing SAL services (like Flow Programmer) to integrate SNMP Ethernet switches into SDN. Now my question is:

1) What kind of SNMP switch device are you using in your development?
2) Can we get something similar to do system test? otherwise any recommendation for doing system test?

Thanks/Luis

====================================================================
本信件可能包含工研院機密資訊，非指定之收件者，請勿使用或揭露本信件內容，並請銷毀此信件。 
This email may contain confidential information. Please do not use or disclose it in any way and delete it if you are not the intended recipient.

====================================================================
本信件可能包含工研院機密資訊，非指定之收件者，請勿使用或揭露本信件內容，並請銷毀此信件。 
This email may contain confidential information. Please do not use or disclose it in any way and delete it if you are not the intended recipient.

====================================================================
本信件可能包含工研院機密資訊，非指定之收件者，請勿使用或揭露本信件內容，並請銷毀此信件。 
This email may contain confidential information. Please do not use or disclose it in any way and delete it if you are not the intended recipient.